Corner Booth Press

Democrats won Congress. Now fund the $200 million housing program

The Senate’s November spending draft leaves the grants without a line item. Democrats should write them in and make cities publish move-in dates and rents.

10 min read
Windows glow in a cluster of apartment towers in Minneapolis at dusk.
Riverside Plaza and Cedar High Apartments in Minneapolis, 2019.
Photo credit
Riverside Plaza at Dusk by Chad Davis · CC BY 2.0. Cropped for display.

The federal housing department has until July 11 to set up the Innovation Fund for places that have managed to build more homes. A city could use a grant to get water and sewer service to a site where it wants apartments. Congress authorized $200 million for fiscal 2027. The Senate spending bill released this week has no line for the fund.

Democrats won both chambers in the November midterms. They’ll take office in January with Donald Trump still in the White House and the power to put their own numbers in an appropriations bill. I’d put the $200 million in. I’d also ask the housing secretary, at a hearing people can watch, how long it would take the first successful applicant to get from the federal award to a building permit. A mayor should be able to answer the next question. When can someone move in, and what will the rent be?

In the Associated Press voter poll, six in ten voters in households making less than $50,000 said the cost of living was crucial to their vote. More than half of voters in that income group backed Democrats for the House. That poll covers a lot more than rent. It does tell Democrats something about who just put them in charge and what was on their minds. I’d start with a bill that could help people who can’t afford a down payment and may be one rent increase away from needing a different apartment.

House Democrats promised much more the last time they won Congress and the White House. Five years ago their House majority passed Build Back Better with a housing package of roughly $150 billion. It included money to repair public housing, build and preserve affordable homes, and expand rental assistance. Most of that housing package disappeared from the reconciliation bill that ultimately became the Inflation Reduction Act. The law did fund energy and climate upgrades for some subsidized apartments. Congress still walked away from most of the work the House had voted for.

A curved concrete office building looks out onto a paved plaza.
HUD’s former headquarters at the Robert C. Weaver Federal Building in Washington, D.C., in 2009.
Photo credit

The Biden administration did try a smaller approach. In 2024 it awarded $85 million to the first 21 recipients of its program to remove local barriers to housing. That money could help a planning department change rules or a community preserve affordable units. That was worth doing. It gave a local planning office some help without coming close to providing the rental assistance the House had voted for.

This week the Senate Appropriations Committee said HUD still hadn’t invited applications for $100 million Congress provided for a later round of PRO Housing in fiscal 2025. The same committee proposes $50 million for PRO Housing now. That is a separate program from the Innovation Fund. Democrats can vote for both, then ask at the same hearing when the agency will accept applications for the money it already has. A city that learns in March when it can apply has time to line up the rest of the financing. A city that finds out after its construction bids expire may have to start again.

I think the new majority can get a housing appropriation past this White House. Elizabeth Warren and Tim Scott helped get the housing bill through the Senate. It passed there 85 to 5 in June and became law on July 11 without Trump’s signature. I wouldn’t hold the housing money until a bargain comes together on everything else Democrats want from this president. We saw where that put housing in the last big reconciliation deal.

Realtor.com’s October report found that median asking rent for studios through two-bedroom apartments in the 50 largest metro areas rose from a year earlier for the first time since June 2023. The increase was a dollar. The number of apartments finished in the third quarter fell by roughly a quarter from a year earlier. Renters shopping this year got some benefit from buildings that were financed and started in a different market. Builders were also starting fewer apartments. New starts ran roughly nine percent below the previous year’s pace.

Tower cranes rise above a cluster of Miami high-rises under construction.
High-rise construction in Miami’s Brickell neighborhood, 2015.
Photo credit

Lissette Calderon, a Miami developer interviewed by Realtor.com, described how financing and operating costs have made projects harder to get off the ground. A council can legalize the building and still have a vacant lot on its hands when a lender runs the numbers. I want the zoning vote anyway. I also want a lender to see where the sewer connection will come from, what the builder is putting in, and which public money is actually available.

CBS News reported Friday on ideas for helping buyers with very small down payments, including a $1,000 down payment proposed by former Biden economic adviser Lael Brainard. Plenty of renters could pay a monthly mortgage but have never been able to save the upfront cash. I’m sympathetic. Put more bidders in front of the same row of starter homes, though, and the seller gets a chance to capture part of the help. A renter who can’t afford a mortgage even with the help gets very little from that contest.

In Detroit’s North End, work started this month on a project that will add 32 homes in duplexes and fix up 11 existing apartments. Axios Detroit reported that leasing was expected to start in October 2027. A household nearing the end of a lease this winter may have to renew before any of the new homes are ready to lease. If the schedule slips, it could renew twice. I’d rather hear the details of that calendar in a budget hearing than another estimate of how many people a national program might someday help.

To qualify for the new fund, a local government or tribe has to show it’s already building homes faster. HUD will have to publish the way it measures that improvement at least 90 days before it opens applications. There’s a separate section for planning grants. It expressly keeps that money out of construction and rehabilitation. Congress should fund the Innovation Fund at its authorized level and use hearings to put the two programs side by side. I’d like to hear what a town needs to start work on a site it has already approved. There should be a contractor’s estimate or a letter from the water department with the application.

Minneapolis offers a reason to believe local rules can matter. The Pew Charitable Trusts found that between 2017 and 2022 the city added 12 percent to its housing stock and rents rose one percent. The rest of Minnesota added four percent and saw rents rise 14 percent. Minneapolis had made it easier to build apartments in more places and had pared back parking requirements. The comparison can’t assign those results to a single vote or tell another city what its rent will be five years from now. It does show a city can add a substantial number of homes without seeing the same rent growth as the rest of its state.

A New York apartment building with a wavy brick facade seen from the street.
Apartment construction on Mulberry Street in New York, 2009.
Photo credit
290 Mulberry St by Lauren Manning · CC BY 2.0.

Democratic cities have also helped make the problem. It’s easy to support apartments in a regional plan and much harder to tell homeowners on a particular block that their city is about to allow them. The New York City Council’s 2024 zoning deal let more homes go up around transit and made room for small additional units on some lots. The city estimated its changes could produce 80,000 homes over 15 years. A year of permit data would tell us which allowances builders can actually use and which still need work. I’d ask cities seeking grants to report how many homes they expect, how many they’ve permitted and how many they’ve finished.

The rules of the fund also require a closer look at who can afford the result. The law’s definition of attainable housing can include households earning up to 120 percent of the local median if most units are affordable at 60 percent of that median or below. A building can meet that definition while the cheapest apartment is still too expensive for a part-time home care worker. The grant announcement should show the rent and income bands. It should say how many units will take vouchers and how many will be within reach of a tenant earning far less than the area median.

The Associated Press reported this fall that some apartments with income restrictions in Denver and Portland had vacancies even as poorer residents struggled to find housing. That can happen when the people who need a home earn too little for the rent on offer. A public report that says 100 affordable homes opened should also tell us how many are still empty and what tenants pay for the ones they’ve rented. If the apartments are empty at the rents in the financing plan, the housing authority ought to have a way to bring in deeper assistance.

Metal balconies overlook a courtyard at Renaissance West End Flats.
Denver’s Renaissance West End Flats provides apartments for low-income households. Photo from 2012.
Photo credit

I’d put more money into rental assistance and repairs to existing homes in the same spending bill. A voucher can help a family pay rent while new apartments are still under construction, provided it can find a landlord who will take it. Repair money can keep apartments available that might otherwise sit empty or deteriorate. If Congress only helps the people who can wait for the next building, it will miss many of the people the housing bill is supposed to serve.

There’s a land deal worth offering, too. A city with a site it can spare near a bus line could lease the land for a long term and require below-market rents. The city would still own the site when the apartments need major repairs. I’d want the agreement to say who pays to maintain the building. Otherwise the next council can end up voting for an emergency roof repair on a project it thought it had paid for already.

A sewer line can serve a second project after the first one opens. I’m willing to finance that kind of infrastructure up front when the city has approved the homes, can show which sites it will serve, and can carry the debt if construction takes longer than expected. The agreement should spell out labor standards and opportunities for apprentices on publicly financed work. It should also give the town a way to recover money if a developer sells the site without building the homes.

A worker stands inside a timber-lined sewer excavation.
Sewer construction on Seattle’s Lander Street, 1910.
Photo credit
Lander Street sewer construction, 1910 by Seattle Municipal Archives, item 52086 · CC BY 2.0.

Every Democrat who asks for more apartments should expect a call from someone who likes the parking lot where the apartments are supposed to go. That’s part of voting to build. And if Congress takes money out of public housing repairs to fund construction, tenants in a building that already needs work will wait longer. I would protect repair and rental assistance in the spending bill and pay for additions openly, including with higher taxes on high incomes where Congress needs a continuing source of revenue. Borrow for a sewer line that will be in the ground for decades. Pay for next year’s vouchers out of next year’s revenues.

The spending bill released this week belongs to the Congress that is still in office. I’d ask its appropriators to put the fund in the final deal. If they leave it out, the incoming majority can put it in the first funding bill it writes. Either way, the committees should ask HUD to come in before July and show how it will pick places that can break ground. If a small city has a good site and a weak planning office, pairing it with technical help is a better use of federal staff than rewarding whichever city hires the best grant writer.

For each funded site I’d put the building permit, the date work starts and the expected opening on a public list, with the promised rents beside them. If the opening slips because the town never signed the water contract, the next hearing should start with the person who can sign it.

Put a follow-up hearing on the calendar before the first grants go out. Ask officials from projects that have opened to bring copies of signed leases with the tenants’ details removed. I want to see the deposits and fees alongside the rents. If the cheaper apartments are still empty, I’d ask the housing authority what it costs a tenant to get through the door on the first day.

Sources
Share this story

Related stories

Coal miners with helmet lamps wait behind a wire elevator gate.Politics / Opinion

Who gets to measure the dust coal miners breathe?

Democrats won Congress days before mine regulators proposed changing how they enforce the silica limit. Keep the limit, and let mines change how they test only if workers are just as well protected.

8 min read
Cranes reach over a container ship stacked with cargo at dusk.Politics / Opinion

Trump’s tariffs should come with an expiration date

After losing both chambers in the midterms, Republicans should back a bill that gives most new tariffs 60 days unless Congress passes a law to keep them.

10 min read
Rep. Veronica Escobar in her official House portrait.Politics / Opinion

Congress should see what ICE got for its money at Camp East Montana

Trump directed contractors to alert the White House when Congress asks about their work for the executive branch. Congress should require ICE to show what it got for its money in El Paso before the agency can commit to a longer deal.

5 min read

Search stories